Cabinet Chaillot - Jurinea Action for Infringement Jurinea Form 1112 Parties to the case Composition pharmaceutique collyre antiallergique (French patent) AMM (French patent) CCP (French patent) Solution aqueuse stérile sensiblement limpide d'un principe actif (French patent) n° 72 16640 (French patent) versus 06-15-99, TGI de Paris (First Instance) Domain --- Issue of law Result Novelty No --- Prior disclosure of the claimed product Yes --- Novelty of certain technical characteristics (Intellectual Property Code art: R 612-16) No Inventive step No --- The man skilled in the art shows inventive activity by defining a range of values No --- Non-inventive use of a type of compounds known for their known properties Yes --- Non-inventive use of a particular compound known for its known properties Yes --- Inventive use of a compound in spite of a damage of a general nature No --- The man skilled in the art shows inventive activity by defining a range of values No Enacting terms: Invalidation of the patent Yes Publication(s): PIBD 2000, Ref.: 695, III, 157

Last updating : 12-10-06
Copyright © Cabinet Chaillot 1997 - 2004