Cabinet Chaillot - Jurinea Action for Infringement Jurinea Form 982 Parties to the case FLACON DE PARFUM TRONCONIQUE ET BOUCHON SPHERIQUE (Unfiled design) versus FLACON DE PARFUM TRONCONIQUE ET BOUCHON SPHERIQUE (Commercialized model) 03-15-00, CA de Paris (Reference court) Domain --- Issue of law Result Design infringement Yes --- Exportation Yes Prejudice evaluation --- Lower quality Yes --- Lower price Yes --- Sells missed in France No --- Sells missed in foreign states Yes --- Different customers No Enacting terms: Order on the ground of Art 700 NCPC 7,622 Euros Patrimonial prejudice 316,568 Euros Moral prejudice 152,449 Euros Publication(s): PIBD 2000, Ref.: 701, III, 356 09-17-97, CA de Paris (Appeal) Domain --- Issue of law Result Copyrights titularity --- Copyrights cession by the creator Yes Protection under the design right --- Existence of an anteriority No --- New combination of known elements Yes Protection by copyrigths (Book I) Yes --- Impression of the author personnality Yes Comparaison of the designs --- The original parts can be totally found Yes --- Inoperative differences in the accessory details Yes Design infringement Yes Prejudice evaluation --- Lower price Yes --- Different customers No --- Will to draw profit from the investments Yes Enacting terms: Damages Fine (per day of delay) Destruction Yes Publication of the decision (maximum) Order on the ground of Art 700 NCPC 6,097 Euros Provisions 22,867 Euros Publication(s): PIBD 1997, Ref.: 644, III, 658

Last updating : 12-10-06
Copyright © Cabinet Chaillot 1997 - 2004