Cabinet Chaillot - Jurinea Action for Infringement Jurinea Form 989 Parties to the case MOTIF NORDIQUE SUR TISSU (2 FLOCONS DE NEIGE ET 2 FLEURS STYLISEES DISPOSES EN QUINCONCE) (Unfiled design) versus MOTIF NORDIQUE SUR TISSU (2 FLOCONS DE NEIGE ET 2 FLEURS STYLISEES DISPOSES EN QUINCONCE) (Unfiled design) 11-19-99, CA de Paris (Appeal) Domain --- Issue of law Result Copyrights titularity --- Distinct cession of each rights (L131-3) Yes --- Copyrights cession by the creator Yes Protection under the design right Yes --- Existence of a whole anteriority No --- New combination of known elements Yes Protection by copyrigths (Book I) Yes --- Impression of the author personnality Yes Comparaison of the designs --- Inoperative differences in the accessory details Yes Design infringement Yes --- Quasi-servile reproduction Yes Prejudice evaluation --- Success of the infringed design No Enacting terms: Damages Interdiction (by established infraction) Destruction Yes Publication of the decision (maximum) Order on the ground of Art 700 NCPC 7,622 Euros Publication(s): PIBD 2000, Ref.: 694, III, 144

Last updating : 12-10-06
Copyright © Cabinet Chaillot 1997 - 2004