Cabinet Chaillot - Jurinea
Action for Infringement

Jurinea Form 256
Parties to the case SECRET PLEASURES (Mark)
versus PRIVATE PLEASURES (Mark)

03-31-99, CA de Paris (Appeal)
Domain
--- Issue of law
Result
Infringement of the mark Yes
--- Illicite imitation of the mark Yes
Comparaison of the signs
--- Reproduction of the non protectable term No
--- Intellectual similitude Yes
--- Indivisible whole Yes
Speciality of goods and/or services
--- Identity of goods or services
------ Perfumes - and - Perfumes
Yes
--- Similarity of goods or services
------ Perfumes - and - Clothing
No
Enacting terms: Invalidation of the mark Partly
Damages 7,622 Euros
Interdiction (by established infraction) 152 Euros
Publication of the decision (maximum) 13,720 Euros
Order on the ground of Art 700 NCPC 4,573 Euros
Order to pay costs to the defendant Yes

Publication(s): PIBD 1999, Ref.: 681, III, 330

09-06-96, TGI de Paris (First Instance)
Domain
--- Issue of law
Result
Infringement of the mark Yes
--- Illicite imitation of the mark Yes
Speciality of goods and/or services
--- Similarity of goods or services
------ Perfumes - and - Clothing
No
--- Identity of goods or services
------ Perfumes - and - Perfumes
Yes
Comparaison of the signs
--- Intellectual similitude Yes
Enacting terms: Invalidation of the mark Partly
Damages 7,622 Euros
Order on the ground of Art 700 NCPC 1,524 Euros

Publication(s): PIBD 1996, Ref.: 622, III, 616

Last updating : 12-10-06
Copyright © Cabinet Chaillot 1997 - 2004